Should we clone Patient Opinion?

How far can you push the Patient Opinion model? We've been thinking about this a lot as we get ready for our MyPublicServices Conference that we are putting on in November. We know that its surprisingly easy to extend it to other countries (providing you have great local people to work with!) and our Catalan, Spanish and Italian versions should go live soon. But what about extending sideways to other sectors within the UK? What about Social Work Opinion? Or Education Opinion? Well, quite a few people are trying to do this and we wish them well as we have no ambition to extend beyond health and social care. But we do have some thoughts about this extension?

First off does it make any sense to have a single system of feedback? Apart from convenience of accessing and promoting a single site (which can be handled in much better ways than creating a single portal) does the citizen gain anything else? Well, yes, if it means they can tell complex stories involving multiple providers, issues and places in a way that makes sense to them. But to do this well the system needs be able to handle each bit of the journey in an appropriate way. Commenting about your social worker for example probably raises issues particular to this field that need to be handled sensitively.

Which begs the question what is the nature of ‘appropriate’? Is there anything we learnt from Patient Opinion about what ‘appropriate’ means for web-based platforms?

Roughly speaking public services can be divided into those that are transactional and those that are based on some kind of personal relationship. The touchstone here is whether you, as a user, have a relationship with at least one or two of the key people providing the service. FixMyStreet and its generic descendents FixMyRailways, FixMyRoadworks and FixMyFlyTipper are all clearly transactional. Social Work Opinion, Pupil Opinion and Probation Opinion would, like Patient Opinion, be at the relational end. Our guess is that it’s much easier to build a generic service for transactional services than for those based on relationships.

This is only in part because the ethical, legal and business knowledge needed to generate income from relational feedback is highly specialized. It’s because users want a relationship. They want to feel heard by their doctor, they want a response from their teacher, their probation officer. They want to touch, feel, affect the relationship they already have. That’s why they are posting their story in the first place.  Just providing a place that does to the professionals they have been dealing with my cathartic to the angry and the frustrated. But it does a violence to the majority of people who come on sites like Patient Opinion and I Want Great Care.

Complicating all this further is the rhetoric of the web. Built around consumer sites both the rhetoric and the formal research about web users tends to concentrate on desire driven events. Health care, social work and the criminal justice tend to be fear and anxiety driven. Just think about the difference between sharing the story of your wedding on FaceBook or the story of your haemarhoidectomy on Patient Opinion. Get the picture? So the standard script about web sites – that use matters, that hits and clicks are the only currency – just doesn’t work on for many public services. Not only does this mean that the standard advertising driven models don’t hold up (what services would you advertise on Social Work Opinion?). It also means learning what drives users to use the site has to be discovered. It doesn’t just fall fully formed off FaceBook or out of the Twitter tree.

So where the beef here? Maybe that a generic model is practical for transactional services but that for relational services it’s better to build a flotilla of sister organisations who each specialize in a sector, manage it’s particularly risks, and who know and love it enough to generate income. With the whole lot held together by a loosely evolving software systems that have enough inter-operability to provide seamless storytelling to users. Which is more or less the direction we’re interested in taking Patient Opinion. So if there are any budding fellow travelers out there who want to colonise a new sector, come and talk to us!